15 Best Electric Fireplace Inserts And The Top 3 Mistakes To Avoid

Table of Contents

Are you considering purchasing an electric fireplace insert? Would you like to upgrade your traditional fireplace with an energy-saving, modern fireplace?
 
If yes, you’ve made a great decision.

At A Glance: Our Top 5 Picks for Electric Fireplace Inserts

 
An electric fireplace insert will give you endless hours of warmth and enjoyment. No need to worry about smoke, ashes, and the extra cost that comes with a traditional fireplace.
 
But wait!
 
There are 3 costly mistakes that first-time electric fireplace insert buyers make.
 
Before you commit to a particular brand or model, learn how to avoid these 3 mistakes. This could save you hundreds of dollars and 90% of your future headaches.

Best Electric Fireplace Inserts: A review on the Top 15 electric fireplace inserts as well as a must-read electric fireplace insert buyer's guide. #electricfireplaceinsert #electricfireplace #buyerguide #homedecor #FireplaceLab

Mistake #1: Not Knowing Which Type of Electric Fireplace You Need

There are 2 major types of electric fireplaces: fireplace inserts and freestanding fireplaces.
 
An electric fireplace insert goes inside your wall as a built-in but do not require venting. Install one into an existing fireplace by either sliding it into the empty space or into a mantle.
A freestanding electric fireplace is a unit that you place on the floor against a wall or in a corner. They do not go inside a wall and can be moved from place to place like a space heater.
 
A common misstep new buyers make is to buy a freestanding fireplace when they needed a fireplace insert. Or the other way around.
 
Look closely at the product listing to determine if it’s an insert or a freestanding unit. It should be clear, but it will sometimes be ambiguous, especially with larger units like electric fireplace TV stands.
 
If an electric fireplace insert is still what you are looking for, check out our list below of 2020‘s best electric fireplace inserts. We’ll then discuss the remaining 2 mistakes.

Top 15+ Electric Fireplace insert: (Classic & New Models) 2020

Here are the 15+ latest electric fireplace insert reviews and comparison chart 2020

IMAGEPRODUCT
  • Easy to install
  • Has a 1 year warranty
  • Relatively affordable.
CHECK PRICE →
  • Heats an entire place up to 400 sq. ft.
  • Easy and simple to utilize
  • Could be operated through a remote control
CHECK PRICE →
  • Low Maintenance
  • Produces realistic flames
  • Quick Installation
CHECK PRICE →
  • Vent-free and no hookups required
  • Operates with heat on or not
  • Uses energy efficient, low maintenance LED technology
CHECK PRICE →
  • Attractive
  • Realistic flame
  • Easy to set-up
CHECK PRICE →
  • Beautiful and stunning heat flame output
  • Convenient to use and can be plugged into a regular electrical outlet
  • Variety of flame available and automatic temperature setting
CHECK PRICE →
  • Good-looking and cost-effective supplemental heating
  • The realistic flame visual effect with an excellent heating capability
  • Easy to install even if alone with clear instructions provided
CHECK PRICE →
  • Powerful traditional design and structure
  • Efficiently saves energy
  • Provides heat up to an area of 800 square feet
CHECK PRICE →
  • Safe plug technology
  • Flame effect can be used with or without heat
  • Can warm a 1000 square foot room
CHECK PRICE →
  • Can heat up to 1000 square feet of room space
  • Simple and hassle-free installation
  • Adjustable thermostat that lets you choose your room temperature.
CHECK PRICE →
  • Operates with heat on or not
  • Heats up to 400 square feet.
  • Fits perfectly into any masonry fireplace
CHECK PRICE →
  • Provides a comfortable amount of heat
  • Feel cozy and comfortable with its realistic flame as the light reflects off the wall
  • It is easy to install and no cleaning required
CHECK PRICE →
  • Most realistic flames effects of any fireplace insert we’ve ever tested!
  • Huge library of flames to choose from complete with log crackling sounds.
  • Backlit touch screen and phone app make it easy to control in dark rooms.
CHECK PRICE →
  • Simple installation- it can be plugged into a standard 120 v outlet
  • Ease of use
  • Includes a 1 year warranty
CHECK PRICE →
  • Infrared technology that heats upto 1000 square feet.
  • Can be used with heat on or not
  • Uses 3 Infrared quartz elements for heat
CHECK PRICE →
  • Eco-friendly
  • Attractive design that blends well with your home decor
  • Heat upto 400 square feet
CHECK PRICE →
  • Simple to install
  • Can be used with or without heat
  • Heat up a 400 square foot room
CHECK PRICE →
  • Vent free and perfect for any modern house
  • Energy efficient
  • Heats up to 400 square feet
UNAVAILABLE

Mistake #2: Buying An Electric Fireplace That Can’t Produce Enough Heat

The most common complaint we see from users is that they bought an electric fireplace that can’t produce enough heat to warm up their room.

I can imagine the frustration.

Researching, choosing, and installing an electric fireplace is time-consuming.  The last thing I want happening to you is to go through all that work only to find out at the end that the room is still cold. 

Why does this happen?

Two reasons:

  1. Buyers forget to consider the size of the room is and how much heat output is necessary to warm it OR
  2. They do consider the size and heat output but fail to overcompensate with an electric fireplace that can produce more heat than the room needs

To avoid this costly mistake, do these two things:

  1. First, find out the square footage the room you want to heat
  2. Second, overcompensate by buying an electric fireplace that can produce enough heat to warm up a room that is twice the size. For example, if the room is 250 square feet, get an electric fireplace that can heat a 500 square foot room.

You will be much better off having a fireplace that runs on 50% or 75% of its potential that generates enough heat. As opposed to having a fireplace that is operating at 100% and being just warm enough. Over-compensate in heat output and be happier with more options and increased flexibility.

Electric fireplaces measure their heat output rating using BTUs (British Thermal Unit). The manufacturer will translate that into square feet. But these will just be estimates and are usually overestimated. Overcompensate and get a fireplace that produces more BTUs than you need.

Mistake #3: Buying An Electric Fireplace Insert With The Wrong Dimensions

This is a frequent mistake for new buyers of electric fireplace inserts and is a tricky one to properly avoid.

You need to know the exact dimensions of the space in the wall that the fireplace will fill.

Buying an insert only to find out that it is the wrong size will give you a huge headache. Measure the width, depth, and length multiple times. Pay extra attention to the dimensions of potential electric fireplace inserts.

In addition, consider the size of the fireplace mantel. A mantel that is proportionate to the size of the fireplace and the room will look best. It is common for buyers to buy the right size fireplace insert, but the mantel may not look appropriate for the room.

Here’s a tip:

Outline the area on the wall that the new electric fireplace and mantel will occupy with some blue tape. This will allow you to visualize the placement of the fireplace and mantel in the room. Do this for each fireplace you are considering. Don’t forget to take a photo and compare.

Now that we’ve gone over the 3 most common mistakes by first time buyers, let’s go to the fireplace insert reviews.

Dimplex DFI2309 Electric Fireplace Insert

Best electric fireplace insert reviews -Dimplex DFI2309 Electric Fireplace Insert

Pros
  • Easy to install
  • Has a 1 year warranty
  • Relatively affordable.
  • Comes with an Attractive design
Cons
  • Although the heating function is adequate it is not outstanding.
  • Has minimal control options: 1 fan speed, 1 flame effect

Check Price

Are you looking for a great fireplace to provide you with the warmth and feel of a real fireplace yet it doesn’t require any special electrical tools to install it? Well, the Dimplex DFI2309 Electric Fireplace Insert is your perfect choice. Why is that? This is because all you have to do is just unpack it and simply plug the fireplace insert into a standard household outlet. This fireplace insert is a great idea, if you have an existing fireplace that you are under-utilizing.

The Dimplex DF12309 insert comes with only one flame setting and there are no different light levels or effects meaning that setting a mood is one dimensional. You will enjoy the flame effects produced by the included motor and two 60 watt bulbs. The quiet inbuilt fan forced heater evenly heats up to 400 square feet of room space and also turn on the two 60 bulbs to create an amazing fire’s glow even when the heater is off.

Click here to view 471+ Buyer Reviews

The heater features 2 heat settings: high/ low, 3 switches: heat. On/off and high/low switch and a remote control that enables you to control only the on/ off function. This insert fits perfectly into your existing fireplace or the Dimplex Expandable Trim Kit and provide the beautiful look and feel of a real fire without the smoke, soot and any danger associated with a real flame.

If you are environmentally conscious, you will love this Dimplex DFI2309 fireplace insert since it runs on electricity, meaning that it is combustion free hence doesn’t release harmful gases like carbon monoxide that pollute the environment and better yet, its glass is cool to the touch hence your pets and children can play around it without having to worrying about fire related accidents. If you have a small fireplace that cannot accommodate large wooden logs or you simply don’t want the hassle of building, cleaning or tending a fireplace, the Dimplex DFI2309 insert is recommended to you.

Buy at Amazon

PuraFlame 30″ Western Electric Fireplace Insert with Remote Control

Getting cold in your space? Then, check out this new PuraFlame 30″ Western Electric Fireplace Insert. This innovation from your common fireplace takes its way through the power of LED technology which brings the fire-like experience to your fireplaces. This is completely safe, easy to use, energy convenient and provides heat effectively to your rooms. This is essentially the best way to keep the cold from bothering you any longer!

Best electric fireplace insert - Key Features of the PuraFlame 30

Pros
  • Heats an entire place up to 400 sq. ft.
  • Easy and simple to utilize
  • Could be operated through a remote control
  • Does not overheat quickly
  • Flexible design, temperature, and flame intensity
  • 100% Energy Efficient
Cons
  • It does not heat large rooms. It is not convenient to use in rooms bigger than 400 sq. ft. Make sure to have a smaller area to enjoy its efficiency.

Check Price

What are the users saying about PuraFlame 30″ Western Electric Fireplace Insert?

This product provides heat and gives you comfort efficiently. Additionally, users applauded on how the product is easy to use and install. Though, some comments on how the product creates disturbing noises but this could be glitches upon installation. Make sure to check for loose screws or obstructions that could cause the noises. Also, however, some says that it does not heat the entire room. But like any other equipment, this has limitations. This product heats best on rooms with areas of 400 square feet.

Click Here to View 377+ Buyer Reviews

Read More...

Key Features of the PuraFlame 30″ Western Electric Fireplace Insert

Despite the increasing market competition for LED-based fireplaces, the following are the reasons on why you should choose PuraFlame 30” Electric Fireplace Insert;

Multi Functioned Remote Control
It incorporates a remote control that could be used on switching on and off, temperature adjustments, and on manipulating flame intensity and brightness.

Easy to Install and Uninstall
This new product gives you convenience upon assembling and disassembling it in less time and effort that even first-timers could manage on getting it directly. Also, it consists of a procedure manual that is simple to read and follow.

Adjustable LED Flames
The flames that mimic a realistic fire could be altered to three different intensity and brightness variations that you could choose the way your mood desires to.

100% Energy Saving
This new technology heats an entire room efficiently and at the same time, consumes less energy. With this product, you would not spend more money on paying electric bills.

Sophisticated Design and Structure
It is framed out with a rectangular three sided brick wall design that is embellished through realistic logs and ember beds that brings out the ultimate fireplace experience that you’ll never have.

Is PuraFlame 30″ Western Electric Fireplace Insert Worth the Price?

Absolutely. This product is highly recommended. The price is relatively reasonable for its features and purpose. It heats up well your space and comes with elegant design and fire like experience that gives you total warmth and comfort.

What makes PuraFlame 30” Western Electric Fireplace Insert the Best?

This gives heat to its customers at its best. This product has excellent ratings from its users and its price is absolutely competitive with other similar products available. Aside from that, this product consumes less energy and absolutely easy to install and operate. You won’t ever going to find a product like this.

Buy at Amazon

Overall Conclusion:

If you have problems with your heater, then this might be the best solution you will have. Aside from that, it delivers warmth to your room effectively, this product is easy to install, operate, and clean. This also comes with a multi-functional remote and design that takes you to a good night’s sleep during freezing winter.

Dimplex DFI2310 Electric Fireplace Deluxe Insert – 23″

Best electric fireplace insert reviews -Dimplex DFI2310 Electric Fireplace Deluxe Insert - 23

Pros
  • Low Maintenance since it only requires light cleaning of its glass surface
  • Produces realistic flames
  • Quick Installation- it require no piping or venting.
  • Overheat Protection – includes an internal safety device that auto-shut the inbuilt fan off.
Cons
  • No issue found while using even in recent users opinion.

Check Price

The Dimplex DFI2310 which is a world leader in electric fireplace performance, service and technology, provides you with a high quality fireplace, the 23 inch Dimplex DFI2310. This insert is a great addition to your former fireplace and plugs into any standard household outlet to give your home the warmth of a real fire or just the appearance of one with heat on or not .

The Flame-only operation allows you to enjoy the dancing flame of your place for 4 seasons. The in-built fan comes with 2 speed settings: high and low, that evenly distributes 4,695 BTUs of heat in your entire living room while maintaining the flame effect.

There are also 3 included manual operating switches, low and high heat switches as well as a main switch that turns on all included functions in order to provide beautiful flame effects that combine the appearance of burning logs with the movement a blazing fire in order to achieve a 3D flickering flame. This 23 inch Dimplex insert comes with an advanced technology that offers exceptional realism as well as the electric fireplace logs that provide warmth without polluting the environment.

Click here to view 318+ Buyer Reviews

This unit boasts eco-friendly and child safety functions such as cool to the touch glass, thermostat among others. With the hand-finished LED logs, you will enjoy viewing a natural, inner glow during simulates real burning wood.

This unit contains 2 60-watt LED light bulbs below the log set that produce the most realistic flame effect, a firelight flicker and a pulsating ember bed to give you an illusion of a traditional wood fire. With clean, safe electric operation, the Dimplex electric logs require no venting or piping.

Buy at Amazon

Duraflame DFI020ARU-A004 Electric Fireplace Insert

Best electric fireplace insert reviews -Duraflame DFI020ARU-A004 Electric Fireplace Insert

Pros
  • Vent-free and no hookups required
  • Operates with heat on or not
  • Uses energy efficient, low maintenance LED technology
  • Pulsating, rolling, realistic log set and ember bed
Cons
  • It’s a little bit noisy in its operation

Check Price

Just imagine relaxing with family and friends in the comfort of your own home with the flickering, rolling hearth lighting up your room on a cold winter night. You can get that with the 20 inch Duraflame DFI020ARU-A004 Electric Fireplace Insert that includes a realistic log set and ember bed that also offers you an irresistible option to replace existing gas or wood.

It uses energy efficient long life LED lights, meaning that you will never have to change a bulb. The flickering simulated flames reflect off the back of the existing fireplace and can operate with heat on or not to provide you with a fascinating and aesthetic appeal. You will be fascinated at how real the log set and ember bed looks even when Duraflame insert is not heating.

Click here to view 645+ Buyer Reviews

This unit is a 1,400watt heater that is rated with 4,600 BTUs an hour to effectively heat a room up to 400 square feet. It’s a lightweight, weighing about 13.6pounds thus making it easy to move around and install. When it comes to installing this unit, you don’t need and electrician to set it up.

All you need to do is unpack it and plug the fireplace insert into a standard 120 volt 3-prong outlet. Once the insert is plugged in, you can use the included multi-function remote control to adjust the flame and heat settings and also turn the electric fireplace insert on and off. Nonetheless, the Duraflame fireplace insert is 20 inches wide to suit different styles and sizes of any fireplace.

Buy at Amazon

Classic Flame 36EB110-GRT Built-in Electric Fireplace Insert 36″

Pros
  • Attractive
  • Realistic flame
  • Easy to set-up
  • Supplemental heat source
Cons
  • A little it noisy in its operation.

Check Price

Creating a modern looking in-built hearth is an amazing idea for modern -day homes or anyone on premium space. The 36-inch Classic Flame 36EB110-GRT electric fireplace insert which offers you with the ambiance and warmth of a real fireplace has a black finish that blends in perfectly with your home decor.

Whether you are going through new construction or renovations, you will be able to enjoy the benefits of a fireplace that is easy and quick to install. You may choose to install using the included attachable 3-prong plug or an integrated junction box for hard-wiring to a 120v electrical circuit application.

Classic Flame 36EB110-GRT inserts offers the most realistic flame effect technology with the included long life LED lights. The on screen indicator is controlled manually by a backlit display and a digital time function or by a remote. This feature shows any new function settings within 4 seconds, after which it fades away. A multifunctional remote that uses 2 CR2 batteries is included to enable you to change the Classic Flame settings’ from anywhere in the room.

Click here to view 164+Buyer Reviews

The Classic Flame 36EB110-GRT is rated with 4,400 BTU, and can provide plenty of supplemental zone heating for up to 400 square feet. Its flame effect can be operated with heat on or not and still provide you the ambiance of a gentle rolling fire all year round.

You will get hypnotized by the included traditional log set that provides beautiful flames as well as a pulsating glowing ember bed. You can even adjust the brightness of your fire with included 5different settings in order to get a perfect flame. Additionally, you can adjust your room temperature using the featured thermostat.

Buy at Amazon

Classic Flame 28II300GRA Infrared Quartz Electric Fireplace Insert

If you want to immediately bring your old fireplace to life, then it’s time to know more about Classic Flame 28II300GRA 28 Inches Infrared Quartz Fireplace Insert. This easy-to-install electric fireplace insert can replace your current fireplace with the use of a trim kit or a fireplace mantel, and these are both sold separately. For an all-year round of comfort and enjoyment, it has amazing flame effect that can be used with or without the presence of heat.

Best electric fireplace insert 2018: Classic Flame 28II300GRA Infrared Quartz Fireplace Insert

Pros
  • Beautiful and stunning heat flame output
  • Convenient to use and can be plugged into a regular electrical outlet
  • Variety of flame available and automatic temperature setting
  • It provides up to 1,000 square feet of heating zone coverage
Cons
  • Faint whirring sound after months of used possibly due to incorrect mounting or installation so checking the screws and frame is important
  • Heating not close to the traditional fireplace but the range is impressive up to 1,000 square feet heating zone area

Check Price

The Classic Flame 28II300GRA 28 Inches Infrared Quartz Fireplace Insert is advanced with Safe Plug to ensure that the temperature is continuously monitored through its built-in thermometer. If the plug temperature increases above the safe levels, the safer plug automatically shuts off to prevent dangerous fire and overheating. The heater is operated as normal after the plug and outlet have cooled back to normal temperatures. Now, you have the peace of mind and confidence that you are safely operating your fireplace insert.

Now, you can heat your entire room and your home all day with the energy-efficient fireplace insert. It is the best economic choice, reducing your electricity bills, most especially with the rooms that are only used during certain times of the day, such as bedrooms, living rooms, basements, and dens.

With zone heating, this is an effective method to provide utmost comfort to your room by shutting of the heated air blown to various zones or sections of your home which are not occupied.

Click Here To View 98+ Buyer Reviews

Read More...

If you want a portable heater so you can achieve greater control over the heat distribution in your home, the Classic Flame 28II300GRA 28 Inches Infrared Quartz Fireplace Insert is for you, harnessing the money and energy savings of zone heating.

You can warm your desired room without spiking your electricity bills by turning down the thermostat. You can place the heater in any room, allowing you to decide the suitable temperature for a particular room because not all rooms need a similar amount of heat.

Experience individualized comfort and control because different members of the household have varying individual needs for heat. You can set the temperature without disturbing other household members. Zone heating can provide you more control for customizing the temperature of the various sections of your home, in addition to reducing the wear and tear on your home’s HVAC unit.

The dancing flames are very relaxing and achieve comfortable warmth all year round. Classic Flame 28II300GRA is a good investment for bigger energy savings and unmatched convenience.

Classic Flame 26II310GRA Infrared Quartz Electric Fireplace Insert

With the Classic Flame 26II310GRA 26″ Infrared Quartz Fireplace Insert, you can achieve the perfect ambiance of an efficient and warm fireplace every time. It has the capability to provide supplemental zone heating coverage up to 1,000 square feet. With the infrared heat technology, it helps in maintaining a consistent natural humidity in the air, which results in the comfortable and moist heat without drying indoor air. The Spectra Fire Plus technology provides 5 flame speed settings you can choose from depending on your needs and preferences.

Best electric fireplace insert reviews: Classic Flame 26II310GRA Infrared Quartz Electric Fireplace Insert

Pros
  • Good-looking and cost-effective supplemental heating
  • The realistic flame visual effect with an excellent heating capability
  • Easy to install even if alone with clear instructions provided
  • Great customer service with issues immediately addressed
Cons
  • Not super warm like a real fireplace but effective as a typical heater with the same strength

Check Price

The  Classic Flame 26II310GRA 26″ Infrared Quartz Fireplace Insert has 5 flame effect colors including Spectrafire, Amethyst, Midnight Fire, Sapphire, Campfire, and auto cycle. You can use it with or without the presence of heat. This is also smoke-free and without special vents required. It is also equipped with a fire prevention technology through Safer Plug.

You can safely install this fireplace insert in any room because all you need is to plug it in and you are all set. Its versatility and durability are unmatched that is what Classic Flame products are known for. Given these qualities, you’ll surely be proud to own one so you can enjoy the benefits this insert brings.

This is a 5,200 BTU heater providing effective and efficient supplemental zone heating up to 1,000 square feet. It has a 9-hour automatic shut-off timer for your utmost convenience.  The flame effect can be managed with or without heat, thus providing a warm atmosphere of a gentle rolling fire at all times. Now, you can create the best mood and warm ambiance for any style with the Spectrafire Plus, offering 125 flame effect options you can choose from.

Click Here To View 73+ Buyer Reviews

Read More...

You can set the mood depending on your needs and preference making it more relaxing or uplifting. Whether you are dining, reading a newspaper, watching TV, playing video games, or simply bonding with your family, the Classic Flame 26II310GRA fireplace heater can help you feel more comfortable, allowing you to enjoy every moment at its best.

The infrared heat can help prevent dry air that can also dry the airways and the skin. The natural humidity in the air provides a comfortable heat and taking care of your family’s health. The adjustable thermostat gives you the capability to choose the best temperature of your room. It is a very good investment as a supplemental heating for your main heat source.

Achieve the perfect temperature so you can enjoy your indoor activities to the fullest. It comes with a great price and the best value because of the best features and benefits the Classic Flame 26II310GRA offers. Enjoy the comfortable warmth it provides every time!

ClassicFlame 36EB220-GRT 36″ Traditional Built-in Electric Fireplace Insert

Winter is coming. You need to prepare your packs of the sweater to survive through the freezing cold. You keep yourself warm by drinking coffee or tea. But is it enough to get ready for winter? Well, ClassicFlame 36EB220-GRT 36″ Traditional Built-in Electric Fireplace Insert saves the day. It is created and designed to make your cold days turn brighter and warmer by providing heat to your space. By owning this exquisite fireplace, you’ll be undeniably prepared for battling not just winter but when cold days arrive.

Best electric fireplace insert - ClassicFlame 36EB220-GRT 36

Pros
  • Powerful traditional design and structure
  • Efficiently saves energy
  • Provides heat up to an area of 800 square feet
  • Provides variation to flame brightness and intensity
  • Flame Effect is utilized even with no heat
Cons
  • You need to meet the compliance with the local and national codes of electric safety to install this equipment. Though this is a bit hassle, considering this is for you and your family’s security and safety.
  • This could be a little noisy because of the fan in the heater. This is yet normal especially fans help to cool your heaters to prevent it from causing a fire. But if it gets too noisy, make sure to check if there are obstructions within your equipment.

Check Price

What are Users Saying About ClassicFlame 36EB220-GRT 36″ Traditional Built-in Electric Fireplace Insert?

This electric fireplace exhibits a traditional and realistic fireplace experience that effectively provides heat to your place. Though there are also drawbacks coming from a couple of users saying that this produces loud sounds from the heater. Check if there are obstructions or loose screws in your equipment. Also, there are users commending how it does not heat their house efficiently. Remember, that this equipment is ideal for rooms with the area surrounding 800 square feet. To heat your room, make sure it’s below the required area to maximize the experience.

Click Here To View 164+ Buyer Reviews

Read More...

Key Features of the ClassicFlame 36EB220-GRT 36″ Traditional Built-in Electric Fireplace Insert

Multi-Functional Remote
There’s no need to stand up or reach out your electric fireplace’s thermostat! This product has its own remote that allows you to control temperature settings of your room. This also functions upon switching on and off your electric fireplace.

Multiple Flame Effects
This product comes up with five different flame transitions varying its brightness and intensity as what the user wants. Also, this includes a log set with sparkling ember bed that intensifies the traditional fireplace experience.

Zone Heating
This heating method is definitely one of the best things that you should employ for your homes. This product enjoys and applies the heating method. By using this, you will in control of the heat distribution of your home and you will save energy and money because you don’t need to buy multiple heaters to provide warmth to each room of your house.

Traditional Design with LED Technology
This state of the art technology creates a close replica of a realistic fire being enclosed in a black rectangular frame that brings sophistication, comfort and traditional ambiance in your room.

Is ClassicFlame 36EB220-GRT 36″ Traditional Built-in Electric Fireplace Insert worth the price?

Absolutely. You won’t regret purchasing this. Though it’s a bit expensive, imagining the use and the benefits that you’re going to experience with this from its energy and heat distribution efficiency to its exquisite design and features. This product is worth taking a shot especially to those who want to have a traditional fire like experience.

What makes ClassicFlame 36EB220-GRT 36″ Traditional Built-in Electric Fireplace Insert the best?

Generally, the customers approved on using this electric fireplace. It efficiently heats their place and provides them a different traditional and realistic fireplace experience that they have never found to another electric fireplace.

Buy at Amazon

Verdict

The product is definitely recommended. Aside from its traditional design, this provides heat effectively up to 800 ft. of your space. Though it has drawbacks, you could return the product with its two-year exclusive warranty. Don’t you worry, the manufacturer is absolutely reliable and doing their best on bringing its service to its loyal customers.

Classic Flame 33II310GRA Infrared SpectraFire Plus Insert -33″
Best electric fireplace insert reviews -Classic Flame 33II310GRA Infrared SpectraFire Plus Insert -33 Inch

Pros
  • Safe plug technology
  • Flame effect can be used with or without heat
  • Timer function that auto shuts from 30 minutes to 9 hours and a digital thermostat.
  • Can warm a 1000 square foot room
Cons
  • Takes a while for a room to heat up

Check Price

The Classic Flame insert is a great addition to your existing firebox and using a fireplace mantel or a trim kit, you can easily retrofit your wood burning fireplace. The Classic Flame 33 inch Electric Fireplace Insert is the perfect union of style, safety and functionality, and has a powerful heat source that generates enough warmth create a comfy experience.

This insert harnesses energy saving ability of zone heating using the PowerHeat feature. The PowerHeat feature and the infrared Quartz heating tubes can heat up a 1,000 square foot room and also create the perfect lighting for added room ambiance. The heating tubes used are of high quality and have a 20,000 hour lifespan on 12 hours daily usage.

It also includes a multi-functional remote powered by 2 AAA batteries and this helps adjust your electric fireplace settings with the featured 125 flame-effect options thus creating the perfect ambiance and mood for any style.

Click here to view 75+ Buyer Reviews

If you like, you can select the auto cycle option that lets you sit back and enjoy as the different flame effects rotate through. You will be fascinated by the realistic looking logs and beautiful embers of this fireplace that simulate a real fire. With the energy saving LED technology, you can enjoy lighting with or without heat all year round.

The Classic Flame insert uses SPectraFire Plus flame technology in order to create a sensational flame effects with different options that let you select the featured 5 flame speeds, 5 flame colors and 5 flame brightness levels. You can also mount your flat screen TV 3 feet above this fireplace and enjoy curling up around the fire with your loved ones as you watch your favorite TV programs or movies.

The unit features Safe Plug technology which is an in built thermostat in the rubber 3-prong plug, that detects any overheating within the plug or outlet and turns off the heater in order to avoid unsafe conditions e.g. house fires and electrical blowouts. Nonetheless, you can plug this heater into any standard 120 volt power outlet.

Buy at Amazon

Classic Flame 23II310GRA Infrared Quartz Fireplace Insert – 23″

Best electric fireplace insert reviews -Classic Flame 23II310GRA Infrared Quartz Fireplace Insert

Pros
  • Can heat up to 1000 square feet of room space
  • Simple and hassle-free installation
  • Adjustable thermostat that lets you choose your room temperature.
Cons
  • Flames don’t seem realistic enough like the real fire

Check Price

With the 23 inch infrared quartz electric fireplace insert, you can now enjoy the ambiance and heat of a fireplace all year round. Rated with 5, 200 BTU, this heater is capable of providing supplemental zone heating for upto 1, 000 square feet. The Classic Flame 23II310GRA’s is smoke and vent free and its flame effects can be operated with heat on or not and still provide you with the ambiance of a gentle rolling fire all through the year.

It includes a multi-function remote with 2 AAA batteries, which enables you to adjust your electric fireplace setting with 125 flame effect options in order to create the ideal ambiance and mood for any style. You can also opt for the auto cycle option that lets you sit back and enjoy as the included different flame effects rotate through.

This unit features Spectrafire Plus technology that lets you choose from the 5 flame speed settings which let you adjust from a fast roaring fire to a gentle flickering flame, 5 brightness settings that let you pick the ideal brightness from the available 125 combinations for your room ambiance and 5 flame effect colors that include Sapphire, Amethyst, and SpectraFire, Midnight Fire, auto cycle and Campfire.

Click here to view 53+Buyer Reviews

Also, the Classic Flame 23II310GRA’s infrared heating helps to maintain the natural humidity in the air leading to moist comfortable heat without having to dry out the room’s air. It includes a user’s manual with easy to follow instruction that make its installation simple and hassle free.

This insert can be used together with TV stands with insert capacity, flush mount trims kits, or Classic Flame mantels. Furthermore, it comes equipped with a digital timer function that auto shuts off from 30 minutes to 9 hours, an adjustable thermostat that lets you change your room temperature and safe plug fire prevention technology for added safety by monitoring the plug’s temperature to prevent circuit damage or fire.

Buy at Amazon

Pleasant Hearth LH-24 Electric Log Insert with Heater

Best electric fireplace insert reviews -Pleasant Hearth LH-24 Electric Log Insert with Heater

Pros
  • Operates with heat on or not
  • Heats up to 400 square feet.
  • Fits perfectly into any masonry fireplace
Cons
  • It doesn’t heat large rooms effectively.

Check Price

The pleasant Electric Fireplace heater is a beautiful and an efficient way to heat your living space. With the LH-24 glowing electric log from Pleasant Hearth, you can now instantly add both heat and flame effects with the electric insert or retrofit your existing fireplace.

This environmentally friendly insert plugs into any 120 V outlet and is powered by the energy-efficient (light emitting diode) LED technology to provide the beautiful ambiance of a cozy warm fire to any room without smoke, soot or any other dangerous emissions.

Click here to view 123+ Buyer Reviews

This unit is a multi-setting heat source that produces randomly glowing embers and a realistic flame. Pleasant Hearth LH-24 comes with a 4,600 BTU fan forced heater capable of heating up to 400 sq. feet. It includes a multi-function remote control for adjusting your electric fireplace’s flame projection, and 5 temperature settings to create the ideal ambiance and mood for any style.

The Pleasant Hearth LH-24 fireplace insert can fit into most pre-fabricated and masonry fireplaces in your living room, bedroom etc. It is CSA certified meaning that it meets all the applicable standards and is safe to use by all.

Buy at Amazon

Comfort Glow ELCG251 Electric Heater Log Insert

The Comfort Glow ELCG251 Electric Heater Log Insert, and its firebox projection can bring the glow back to your existing fireplace. It has a built-in heater that can produce 4,600 BTUs of fan-forced heat. The realistic dancing flame is impressive that has beautiful firebox wall projection. With its side mounted control, you can definitely experience total realism with this electric fireplace heater.

Pros
  • Provides a comfortable amount of heat
  • Feel cozy and comfortable with its realistic flame as the light reflects off the wall
  • It is easy to install and no cleaning required
Cons
  • Supplemental heating according to the manufacturer is 700 square feet but this is ideal and perfect to provide comfortable heat up to 400 square feet
  • Beeping remote every time the unit is turned on for alert purposes most especially helpful when the room is dim

Check Price

You would love to go home right away because of the comfort and elegance provided by the Comfort Glow electric log set. As compared to your old fireplace, you don’t have to worry about the mess, smoke, and ash anymore. The design can match any interior décor whether you have a contemporary, Victorian, or country style home.

Upon arrival, it is easy to unpack and install, giving you the utmost convenience and saving your time and effort figuring out how to put the parts together. It arrives fully assembled. This is a good thing for elderly customers or not technically-savvy people. The unit measures 8.5 x 20.5 x 12.2 inches and weighs 15.9 pounds.

It can be mounted to your old fireplace. Because of its weight and product dimension, you can just easily replace your old fireplace with this amazing electric fireplace heater, providing excellent supplemental heating to your living room, bedroom, or office.

When it comes to performance, Comfort Glow ELCG251 will not be left behind. The heat it produces is 4,600 BTUs, giving off a fan-forced heat for the comfortable warmth you and your family deserve. The flame is real-like with a yellow flame that can operate with or without the presence of heat.

Click Here To View 63+ Buyer Reviews

Read More...

Enjoy the superior heating it provides while you are watching TV, reading a newspaper or book, playing video games, or having a rest or sleep. You can keep your room warmer or cooler depending on your mood, needs, and preference, so you can relax and enjoy every indoor activity with your family and friends.

Adjust the flame settings using the user-friendly remote control. It is very convenient to use so you can modify the settings even if you are far from the unit. The Comfort Glow provides an excellent heating, keeping your living room two degrees warmer than the rest of the house.

It is a practical and very good investment, most especially if you tend to get sick on the very cold winter season. Comfort Glow ELCG251 Electric Heater, Log Insert, & Firebox Projection marks the innovative solution for old fireplaces with a reasonable price but unfailing features and performance.

Buy at Amazon

HolloFlame electric fireplace insert

An electric fireplace insert is fantastic for converting your existing wood burning or gas burning fireplace into a cost efficient and safe electric fireplace. By far the most realistic and full-featured electric fireplace insert we’ve ever tested is the 28” inch HolloFlame by MagikFlame.

Pros
  • Most realistic flames effects of any fireplace insert we’ve ever tested!
  • Huge library of flames to choose from complete with log crackling sounds.
  • Backlit touch screen and phone app make it easy to control in dark rooms.
Cons
  • Expensive; one of the most expensive electric fireplaces we’ve ever tested.
  • Looks better in dimly lit rooms; overhead lights can reflect in the glass.
  • Touch screen is a bit sensitive and takes some getting used to.

Check Price

Key Features of HolloFlame electric fireplace insert

Appearance: What is the point of owning an electric fireplace if it doesn’t look realistic?  That must have been the question that inspired the innovative company behind the MagikFlame HoloFlame 28” inch insert. It has the most realistic flames of any insert we’ve ever tested at fireplacelab.com

The Innovative holographic technology uses real flame videos and projects those onto the physical log set to make it appear as if the logs are actually burning and it does so quite convincingly.

Features: The features are almost too numerous to list. The most important is that each flame is accompanied by its own unique log crackling sounds that make the flames not only look realistic but sound realistic as well.

HolloFlame electric fireplace insert also features a built-in touchscreen making it easy to use in a dark room [and goes off after a few minutes of inactivity] and has smartphone apps available so that you can use your favorite device to control your fireplace from any room of your home.

Future versions will even have hands-free voice control using your favorite “smart-speaker” by Amazon or Google and will be released to all customers past and present free of charge.

Heat: There’s no point to owning an electric fireplace unless it’s going to keep you snug as a bug in a rug on a cold winter day and the HoloFlame by MagikFlame will do just that. Boasting a 4,600 BTU infrared quartz heater this electric fireplace insert will take the chill out of your room in style.

Buy at Amazon

Conclusion: The MagikFlame HoloFlame isn’t cheap at around $2550. That being said if you can afford this electric fireplace insert you’re getting the absolute best for your money. We’ve never seen an electric fireplace that looks even close to this one and the features alone are absolutely unrivalled. The flame effects are a sight to behold and have to be seen to be believed.

The logs actually look like they are on fire and you can practically smell the smoke [figuratively] as this thing is running. The HoloFlam is about as close as you can get to a real wood burning fireplaces in terms of visual appeal but its much cleaner, safer, and easier to use than a traditional. Adding one of these to your living room is a no brainer and we feel confident recommending the MagikFlame HoloFlame as the best electric fireplace insert of 2018

AKDY Azfl-EF05-23r Electric Firebox Fireplace Heater Insert – 23″

Best electric fireplace insert reviews -AKDY Azfl-EF05-23r Electric Firebox Fireplace Heater Insert - 23

Pros
  • Simple installation- it can be plugged into a standard 120 v outlet
  • Ease of use
  • Includes a 1 year warranty
Cons
  • Nothing major or bad issues

Check Price

Do you want to quickly transform your gas fireplace or masonry into an electric fireplace without having to put much effort? The 23 inch AKDY 2 Fireplace Heater Insert will do exactly that. This 1,400 watt heater insert comes in a beautiful black finish that harmonizes with your home décor and weighs about 29.5 pounds. It includes a user’s manual with easy to follow instruction that make its installation simple and hassle free.

All you need to do is just plug the fireplace insert into a standard 120 v household outlet. Once the AKDY 23’’ is plugged in, you can use the included remote control to adjust the flame and heat settings as well as turn the electric fireplace insert on and off. This unit is easy to operate, by simply pushing a button .you will get fascinated by its realistic flame effect and a pulsating ember bed to give you an illusion of a traditional wood fire.

Click here to view 111+ Buyer Reviews

The AKDY Azfl-EF05-23r is compact in design hence fits perfectly into your existing fireplace. This unit features an advanced patented electric flame technology that offers exceptional realism. The innovative AKDY flame effect combines the movement of a blazing fire with the appearance of burning logs to achieve a 3D flickering flame.

With the hand-finished LED log set, you can enjoy viewing a natural, inner glow that simulates real burning wood. The electric firebox also contains two 60-watt light bulbs below the log set that produce the firelight flicker and pulsating rolling ember bed for the best illusion of a traditional wood fire.

Buy at Amazon

Infrared Electric fireplace Insert 23II210GRA – 23″

Best electric fireplace insert reviews -Infrared Electric fireplace Insert 23II210GRA - 23

Pros
  • Infrared technology that heats upto 1000 square feet.
  • Can be used with heat on or not
  • Uses 3 Infrared quartz elements for heat
  • Energy saving and doesn’t require gas lines or venting
Cons
  • No major cons were noted with this heater. The few noted were minor and could be easily be solved without the need of a professional

Check Price

The 23″ Infrared Electric Insert 23II210GRA INSERT ONLY is a great addition for your home to provide ambience and warmth for all year round. It has a black finish that blends in perfectly with your home decor and with the energy saving LED technology, you can enjoy lighting with or without heat all year round.

Click here to view 45+ Buyer Reviews

The 23II210GRA INSERT ONLY is smoke and vent free and its flame effects can be operated with heat on or without and still provide you with the ambiance of a gentle rolling fire all through the year. Also, the 23II210GRA INSERT ONLY infrared capable of heating upto 1,000 square feet, helps to maintain the natural humidity in the air leading to moist comfortable heat without having to dry out the room’s air.

Buy at Amazon

AKDY Azfl-EF05-28r Electric Firebox Fireplace Heater Insert 28″
Best electric fireplace insert reviews -AKDY Azfl-EF05-28r Electric Firebox Fireplace Heater Insert 28

Pros
  • Eco-friendly
  • Attractive design that blends well with your home decor
  • Heat upto 400 square feet
Cons
  • Poor heat output for large rooms.

Check Price

If you are not a fan of sleek contemporary inserts, then the AKDY Azfl-EF05-28r Electric Firebox fireplace insert is for you. It provides an ideal alternative to the traditional gas or wood fireplaces and duplicate the feel and beauty of a real fireplace but without pollution or cost related issues of the traditional log fireplaces.

The AKDY Azfl-EF05-28r insert has an amazing curved front panel glass and a black finish on its exterior that makes it complement your home decor. This unit is not just good looking but also a powerful source heat. At 1500 watts, it can comfortably heat up a room of 400 sq. ft. or smaller.

The featured thermostat maintains temperature at a constant level and the included quiet heater fan evenly distributes warm heat from the top front. The flame effect of this unit let you enjoy the feel and beautiful looking faux flames, the main reason why people buy electric fireplaces. When it comes to recreating the traditional flame appearance, this insert doesn’t disappoint. It use a patented electric flame technology that offers authentic realistic flames with a beautiful looking log set and a growing ember bed.

Click here to view 127+ Buyer Reviews

With the included remote that includes settings for brightness, power on/off, flames and temperature that allow you to create the experience of your choice by just touching a button. If you like, you can adjust the flames settings further using the included remote control in order to get a great look for you.

You will be fascinated by the unit’s glowing ember bed that simulates the look of real burning logs when turned on and also produce a beautiful appearance of glowing embers when the flames are turned off. Simply plug the fireplace insert into a standard 3-prong 120-Volt outlet and enjoy the moment.

Buy at Amazon

Classic Flame 23EF031GRP Electric Fireplace Insert – 23″

Best electric fireplace insert reviews -Classic Flame 23EF031GRP Electric Fireplace Insert - 23

Pros
  • Simple to install
  • Can be used with or without heat
  • Heat up a 400 square foot room
  • Adjustable thermostat that lets you decide your room temperature
Cons
  • Has controversial flame effects- some liked them while others complained that they looked fake.

Check Price

You can now enjoy obtaining ambiance and warmth of a fireplace all year round with the quality Classic Flame 23EF031GRP electric fireplace. It comes with adjustable options that enable you to achieve a variety of moods and atmospheres as well as a wide feature set that makes it one of the best offers in the market.

The 23EF031GRP offers you 125 flame effect options that create a great mood and ambiance for any style.The flame effects have an incredible visual fidelity and can be used with heat on or off for all year-round enjoyment.

This unit not only delivers the look of a wood burning fireplace but also the feel with its powerful fan forced heater. Rated with 4600 BTUs, this unit lets you enjoy added comfort with supplemental zone heating capability that heats rooms of up to 400 square feet. The Classic Flame features Spectra Fire plus that aims to provide you with the best customization and visual effects that simulate a real wood burning fire.

Click here to check 59+Buyer Reviews

The SpectraFire Plus offers you 5 flame speed settings which let you adjust from a fast roaring fire to a gentle flickering flame, 5 brightness settings that let you pick the ideal brightness from the available 125 combinations for your room ambiance and 5 flame effect colors that include Sapphire, Amethyst, and SpectraFire, Midnight Fire, auto cycle and Campfire. With the included remote control, you can easily adjust the Classic Flame’s settings from anywhere in the room.

When it comes to assembly, you will not experience any problems associated with difficult installation requirements or complicated assembly instructions. All you have to do is simply take it out of the packaging box and plug into a standard 3 prong wall power outlet. Better yet, this unit uses energy saving, low maintenance LED technology to display realistic flames and ember effect. Moreover, the featured safe plug technology that detects overheating within the plug and turns off the heater to prevent fires or accidents. This means that you can safely install this unit in any room of your house.

Buy at Amazon

ModaFlame LED Ventless Electric Space Heater Built-in Recessed Firebox Fireplace Insert

Best electric fireplace insert reviews -ModaFlame LED Ventless Electric Space Heater Built-in Recessed Firebox Fireplace Insert

Pros
  • Vent free and perfect for any modern house
  • Energy efficient
  • Heats up to 400 square feet
Cons
  • Not producing enough heat for large room.

 

Check Price

If you are looking an attractive, simple and easy to use fireplace insert, then the 23 inch ModaFlame Elwood insert is your excellent choice. This fireplace insert comes with a traditional log, 125 flame effects and the LEDPlus technology that lets you adjust the appearance of your fireplace in order to create the best mood and style for any setting. You can choose from the 3 included flame speeds, 3 brightness settings as well as 3 heat settings: low, high or no heat.

The fame effects can be used with heat on or not and still let you enjoy a beautiful ambience all through the year. This ventless fireplace firebox uses all LED lights, making it an energy saving and a low maintenance option for a number of installations.

This means that will never change a bulb and in turn saving your money and time. The Pleasant Hearth LH-24 fireplace insert is full-featured with on-screen digital thermostat controls and a mufti-function remote. This 5200 BTU smokeless Ventless wall recesses in built fireplace uses 1500 watts to heat up to 400 square feet and requires no gas, mantel, ethanol, insert space, gel cans or chimney. It is vent free hence ideal for any rational or modern home.

Click here to view 10+ Buyer Reviews

With the included full functional control, you can adjust any setting of this electric firebox insert. Additionally, you will appreciate its digital timer that auto shuts off for 30 minutes to 7.5 hours as well as the overheat technology that monitors the temperature in your electrical outlet and shuts off the heater to prevent any unsafe conditions from occurring.

Buy at Amazon

How we Listed these best electric fireplace insert reviews ?

There are numerous brands and models of fireplaces in the market varying in quality, features, functionalities and aesthetic appeal. For this reason, it’s advisable that you choose the best electric fireplace insert that will provide good value for money and still meet your heating needs.

To provide you with the best, comprehensive and honest review, we don’t just pick the simple product description given on less thorough electric fireplace reviews, or that found on the manufacture’s site. Instead, we ask probing questions and dig deep in order to give you all the relevant information you need to make an informed buying decision. We have taken our quality time to test a couple of fireplaces, bringing you the top 12 best electric fireplaces that will sure mesmerize you.

Related Best Electric Fireplace 2020: Top 18 Reviews and Buyer Guide

How to choose the best electric fireplace insert

We have reviewed the best 12 Electric Fireplace of different brands and models, each having different functions and features. Therefore, we have come up with 6 tips that will guide you in choosing your special fireplace insert.

  • Select the heating capacity you need for your room – some can heat upto 400 square feet while others over 1,000 sq. ft.
  • Select the style that best suits your home décor- traditional or contemporary modern style
  • Select the type of fireplace insert that you need for your particular installation: an in-built unit, plugin-in unit or a log insert
  • Select your trim and size: decide whether you want glass doors or trim around the edges
  • Make sure to make a list of any other optional features you want: timer, digital display, remote control etc.
  • Finally shop the best price

Final Thoughts

The electric fireplace inserts lets you upgrade or retrofit to your existing traditional masonry fireplace. The inserts are basically modular fireboxes that are installed into an opening. They are cost effective and energy efficient option that will offer you a beautiful flickering flame effect. You can use the inserts all year round with or without heat and still get to enjoy flames and heat of your choice.

In rare situations you may need a professional electrician to install your electric fireplace insert. For example, if you are dealing with an older home or need to rewire. In those cases, contact your local electrician like this local electrician in Wakefield, or if you are advanced enough to attempt DIY, brush up on your electrical training & advice. It’s always better to be safe than sorry.

Lastly, all these units come with great designs that are visually appealing and enhance your home decor. They run on electricity and are eco-friendly and, safe to your pets and children. If you are looking for an electric fireplace insert, it is recommended that you take time to research and get to know what others are saying about different inserts, make some notes on the highlighted pros and cons then shop wisely. Always keep in mind that the best electric fireplace is the one that best suits your needs.

Related: Best Electric Fireplace TV Stand 2020: Top 12 Reviews and Buyer Guide

Related: Best wall mount electric fireplace 2020: Top 12 Reviews and Buyer Guide