12 Best Modern Gas Fireplace Reviews (Winter 2019)

There is only one thing better than a roaring fire on a cold night; a roaring fire that requires minimal cleanup, and needs no tending; this is what you get with modern gas fireplaces. 

They are the perfect solution if you’re looking to make your house a bit cozier or need an extra source of warmth. Gone are the days when you used to spend a lot of time cutting firewood or regularly buying wood for your furnace. 

Because these fireplaces burn gas, they will produce real flames, be low maintenance, heat a room quickly, be more environmentally friendly and increase the resale value of your home. 

Gas Fireplaces: Reviews of the top 12 gas fireplaces #GasFireplaces #Fireplace #ModernGasFireplace #FireplaceLab

When selecting the best gas fireplace, it is essential to consider factors such as its ventilation, location, BTU rating, safety features, and variable flame control.

In addition, these fireplaces come in different types; knowing the model best suited for you is also an important consideration as there are three main types:

  1. The first type is a fireplace insert, which is usually looked for by people who are renovating or constructing their homes.
  2. The second type is gas log inserts, which can be easily installed in an old wooden fireplace.
  3. The third type is a freestanding gas stove which can be assembled and placed virtually anywhere you want without the need of a hole in the wall. These freestanding units can also serve as a nice corner gas fireplace.

Below we have compiled a list of the 12 best gas fireplaces for you. 

Top 12 Gas Fireplaces

Gas Fireplace ModelBTUDimensionsWeightPrice
Duluth Forge, Autumn Spice Finish Gas Fireplace
Editor's Choice
32,000 BTU45 x 45 x 1545 lbs Check Price
Majestic, Quartz Series QUARTZ32IN Gas Fireplace21,000 BTU36 x 16.3 x 34.194 lbs Check Price
Empire Comfort Systems, Boulevard Linear Gas Fireplace10,000 BTU5.5 x 30.25 x 17.8850 lbs Check Price
Pleasant Hearth, Full Size Heritage Gas Fireplace32,000 BTU45.9 x 16.2 x 44.9141 lbs Check Price
Comfort Glow, Kozy World GFD2042 Belmont Gas Fireplace20,000 BTU26.5 x 35.8 x 38.8115 lbs Check Price
Peterson Real Fyre, Oak Gas Log Set75,000 BTU20 x 2 x 277 lbs Check Price
Pleasant Hearth, VFS2-PH20DT Gas Stove20,000 BTU23.5 x 13 x 25.558 lbs Check Price
Napoleon, Grandville VF Series GVF36-2N Gas Fireplace30,000 BTU13.2 x 37.4 x 35.591 lbs Check Price
Pleasant Hearth, VFS2-PH30DT Gas Stove30,000 BTU31.9 x 14.4 x 28.378 lbs Check Price
Superior, Millivolt Linear Gas Fireplace37,000 BTU17.5 x 53.2 x 38276 lbs Check Price
Comfort Glow, GSD2846 Gas Stove30,000 BTU25.2 x 13.2 x 32.259 lbs Check Price
ProCom, QNSD250T Thermostatic Control Gas Stove25,000 BTU13 x 33.5 x 2549.8 lbs Check Price

Duluth Forge, Autumn Spice Finish Gas Fireplace

Pros
  • Burns two types of fuel
  • Comes with a handy remote system control
  • Does not require duct or chimney
  • Has a large heating capacity 
Cons
  • No hose or other connectivity mechanisms
  • The blower fan is purchased separately 

Check Price

The Duluth Forge modern gas fireplace is designed with a dark-brown wood tone that creates a nice contrast complementing a home’s look. It also has an elegant & realistic flame pattern with lifelike fiber ceramic logs providing a breathtaking home experience. This fireplace is made to produce up to 32,000 BTU of heat, which is enough to heat a 1,500 square foot space.

The Duluth Forge fireplace features a patented dual fuel technology which allows it to burn both liquid propane and natural gas. It also comes complete with remote control functions for on & off as well as temperature control, and six hands painted ceramic fiber logs, numbered and pinned for proper placement. We’ve awarded the Duluth our Editor’s Choice award as the best gas fireplace on this list.

 

Majestic, Quartz Series QUARTZ32IN Gas Fireplace

Pros
  • Easy to install
  • Has Intellifire ignition system
  • Customizable interior
  • Has battery back up 
Cons
  • Top and rear venting is ordered separately
  • Not suitable for large spaces 

Check Price

The Majestic Quartz natural gas fireplace comes complete with the options you want along with the features you need. This natural gas fireplace offers electronic ignition, and an easy to install slim depth design. The versatile interior of the Majestic Quartz allows you to customize it with either traditional or contemporary theme designs depending on your preference.

This natural gas fireplace is designed with a shallow depth which takes up less space making the ambiance accessible to all. The Majestic Quarts produces from 15,000 to 24,000 BTU’s and includes eight ceramic fiber logs which give your fire an elegant, timeless look. This fireplace uses direct vent technology, which removes 100% of combustion exhaust from your space. 

 

Empire Comfort Systems, Boulevard Linear Gas Fireplace

Pros
  • No vent required
  • Includes a combustion board and an on-off wall switch
  • Has a state-of-art safety pilot system
  • Has battery back-up 
Cons
  • Not suitable for large spaces
  • Cabinet wrap and decorative front are purchased separately 

Check Price

The Empire Comfort Systems Linear Fireplace is a modern gas fireplace equipped with an Oxygen Depletion Sensor that continually monitors the CO2 levels and a state-of-the-art safety pilot system that turns off the gas if the flame is extinguished. This natural gas fireplace comes complete with an on-off wall switch to mount outside the unit and a back-up battery switch to standing pilot to continue operating even during power outages.

It has openings in the casing which allow you to route the gas supply from the back, the sides, or from below. This unit produces up to 10,000 BTU’s and does not require a vent. The Empire Comfort System Linear fireplace package includes a non-combustible board for fully or partially recessed installation, a wall switch with 10-ft extension, and a beautiful mesh barrier screen. 

 

Pleasant Hearth, Full Size Heritage Gas Fireplace

Pros
  • Remote controlled
  • Vent free
  • Can heat large spaces 
Cons
  • The blower is purchased separately
  • Limited weight capacity on top 

Check Price

The Pleasant Hearth 46 Full-Size Heritage natural gas fireplace has a rich heritage finish, a dual burner that provides two rows of flame for that real wood fire look, and minimum clearance design which allows ease of installation virtually anywhere.

This modern gas fireplace burns on natural gas only and boasts a BTU of 32,000 making it able to heat up to 1,000 square feet of space. This state-of-the-art fireplace does not require a chimney or flue. The Pleasant Hearth 46 Full-Size Heritage fireplace comes complete with a hand-held thermostat remote control that can be used as an on-off switch. 

 

Comfort Glow, Kozy World GFD2042 Belmont Gas Fireplace

Pros
  • Burns both Natural gas and Propane gas
  • No chimney or vent required
  • Has electronic spark ignition
  • Easy to assemble 
Cons
  • The blower is purchased separately
  • Does not work properly at elevations above 4,500ft. 

Check Price

The Comfort Glow Kozy World Belmont gas fireplace is a compact size, quaint fireplace that has a beautiful and unique styling that adds charm and warmth to any space in your home. The design of this fireplace features artfully carved cabinets and a rich, natural vintage mantel finish and can even be installed as a corner gas fireplace.

This corner gas fireplace provides up to 20,000 BTU’s and boasts a 99% fuel efficiency burner system making it able to heat up to 800 square feet of space. The Comfort Glow unit comes ready to assemble and can be installed flat against a wall or as a corner gas fireplace. A mantle, hearth, firebox, realistic charred oak log set and burner are included. 

 

Peterson Real Fyre, Oak Gas Log Set

Pros
  • Durable
  • Vented burner and gas connection kit included
  • Easy to install
  • Does not require a lot of work 
Cons
  • Expensive
  • The safety valve is purchased separately 

Check Price

The Peterson Real Fyre Log Set only burns with natural gas and is designed for indoor use only. This natural gas log set has cosmetic logs meticulously designed to look and feel like real logs with crusted bark, simulated knots, and exposed sapwood.

The cosmetic log set is reinforced with steel rods for greater integrity and can be lit with the use of a match or lighter, and it runs on gas emitted from the main valve. This natural gas fireplace log set has a BTU output of up to 75,000. The Peterson Real Fyre gas log set includes a burner, Embers, six gas logs, and sand. 

 

Pleasant Hearth, VFS2-PH20DT Gas Stove

Pros
  • Has dual fuel technology
  • Two-year warranty
  • Does not require a flue or a chimney 
Cons
  • No remote control capabilities
  • The blower is bought separately 

Check Price

The Pleasant Hearth, VFS2-PH20DT gas stove features state-of-the-art vent free technology which allows it to work without a chimney or flue. This gas stove has dual fuel technology, which will enable it to burn both propane gas and natural gas. This Pleasant Hearth gas stove has a BTU output of up to 20,000, making it able to heat up to 700 square feet of space.

This gas stove can be used as a fireplace that is thermostatically controlled for maximized comfort and ease of operation. This Pleasant Hearth model needs minimal clearance, which enables you to install it virtually anywhere. If you are going to use propane gas on this corner gas stove / fireplace, you will require a 100-lb tank or larger with two-stage adjustable regulator purchased separately. 

 

Napoleon, Grandville VF Series GVF36-2N Gas Fireplace

Pros
  • Has Oxygen depletion sensors
  • Has On-Off switch
  • Comes with a safety screen 
Cons
  • Top and bottom louvers are bought separately
  • Heavy and bulky 

Check Price

The Napoleon Granville, VF series fireplace, is an easy to use and attractive modern gas fireplace designed with Phazer logs which create a natural wood burning look with dancing flames. This natural gas fireplace offers 50% heat and flame adjustment for maximum comfort and efficiency.

The Napoleon Granville, VF series fireplace, comes complete with an oxygen depletion sensor which shits the pilot off before oxygen drops below a safe level and a switch to turn the furnace on and off for the simple operation. This fireplace features a millivolt ignition and has a BTU output of up to 30,000, making it suitable for large rooms and spaces. It includes a hood, millivolt, fireplace screen, dual receptacle junction box, double flame burner, and an oxygen depletion sensor. 

 

Pleasant Hearth, VFS2-PH30DT Gas Stove

Pros
  • Dual fuel technology
  • Two-year warranty
  • Does not require a chimney 
Cons
  • Noisy
  • Accessories are purchased separately 

Check Price

The Pleasant Hearth, VFS2-PH30DT gas stove might appear small, but it has a BTU output of up to 30,000, making it able to warm up to 1,000 square feet of space. This freestanding gas stove has a minimal design, which makes it possible to install it virtually anywhere and with great ease, including as a corner gas fireplace.

The Pleasant Hearth gas stove features state-of-the-art technology which makes it able to function without a chimney or flue. This gas stove is thermostatically controlled so you can always change the temperature to whichever suits you best at the time. The oxygen depletion sensors on this fireplace shut down the pilot before the oxygen inside reaches unwanted levels. 

 

Superior, Millivolt Linear Gas Fireplace

Pros
  • Does not require a chimney
  • Remote controlled
  • Five-year warranty 
Cons
  • The conversion kit is purchased separately
  • The lighting kit is purchased separately 

Check Price

The Millivolt Linear modern gas fireplace is designed with mood enhancing fireplace interior lighting, and three-piece black reflective porcelain liners. It has a 99% heating efficiency and also allows you to transform your fireplace into a see-through model using a conversion kit which is sold separately. The gas controls on this fireplace are conveniently hidden in the fireplace floor.

It also has an electronic ignition with battery back-up to operate when the power is out. A fully functional remote control is included which can be used to manipulate the lighting, flame, and thermostat. This gas fireplace uses liquid propane and has a BTU output of 29,000- 37,000 and comes complete with transparent glass media. 

 

Comfort Glow, GSD2846 Gas Stove

Pros
  • Durable construction
  • Dual fuel technology
  • Does not require a chimney 
Cons
  • The blower is bought separately
  • May not work correctly at elevations above 4,500 ft. 

Check Price

This Comfort Glow freestanding gas stove has been constructed from heavy-duty steel for durability and features a neutral design which makes it suitable for both classical and modern-designed spaces. The great open-face design allows you maximum flame enjoyment from the charred log set and yellow flames.

This gas stove boasts a massive 30,000 BTUs per hour, making it able to heat up to 1,250 square feet of space. The built-in thermostat allows you to maintain a constant temperature in the room as well as lower the fireplace’s consumption. This gas stove features dual technology meaning it can burn both propane gas and natural gas. The Comfort Glow gas stove comes in color matte black and can be installed as a corner gas fireplace.

 

ProCom, QNSD250T Thermostatic Control Gas Stove

Pros
  • Dual fuel technology
  • Has oxygen depletion sensors
  • Does not require chimney or flue
  • Easy to install 
Cons
  • The blower is bought separately
  • May not operate well at elevations above 4,500 feet 

Check Price

The ProCom gas fireplace is designed with a large viewing area to allow you maximum enjoyment while providing a realistic fire viewing experience. The dual fuel technology on this modern gas fireplace gives you the liberty of using either propane gas or natural gas.

This unit can produce up to 25,000 BTUs of heat from its dual burner heating up to 1,100 square feet of space. The ProCom fireplace does not require a chimney to fully function, and it comes with a built-in thermostat which allows you to switch the cycle of the stove on & off and maintain the desired temperature. This unit comes in black and would also serve well as a corner gas fireplace. 

 

Conclusion

Selecting the best gas fireplace can be a daunting task. We have made this task easier for you by researching and selecting the 12 best gas fireplaces for you. We chose the above fireplaces because of their features, type, accessories, fuel type, and rating.

Once you have selected the right fireplace suited for you, you will have no problems using it as all the above models are easy to assemble, install, and use. A modern gas fireplace is a perfect addition to your living space because it not only warms up the area but also adds beauty and elegance to your house. 

 

FAQ 

  1. What is the best fireplace?

    The best fireplace varies depending on your preferences. The best, however, should have high heat capacity, should be efficient, able to cover large spaces, have added safety features like oxygen depletion sensors, have a thermostat, and modern ignition.
  2. Is a gas fireplace worth it?

    As compared to its counterparts, the best gas fireplaces are worth it as they are more efficient, they cost a fraction of the price of wooden models, they have a better appearance, gas fireplaces are easier to maintain, and remove up to 100% of combustion exhaust.
  3. Do gas fireplaces give off carbon monoxide?

    Yes. Gas fireplaces give off carbon monoxide. This, however, can be avoided by properly maintaining and ventilating your furnace. As a back-up, most ventless gas fireplaces come complete with an oxygen depletion sensor system that automatically turns off the unit when oxygen levels are below a given level.
  4. Is it more expensive to run a gas fireplace?

    No. As compared to electric fireplaces, which cost around 15 pence per KW to run, the gas fireplaces cost 5 pence per KW to run, making it cheaper and more efficient.
  5. How do I convert my fireplace to gas?

    First, you will have to choose the type of gas fireplace you want. A wood-burning stove will require a conversion kit. You will have to clean your chimney first to clear out the built-up creosote. The gas line will have to be extended to service the new gas fireplace. The new gas fireplace will be fitted in your existing masonry work and edges sealed seamlessly. Once installed, we recommend you make an appointment for fireplace inspection. We recommend you hire a fireplace installation expert for this conversion process.
  6. Can I leave my gas fireplace on?

    If your fireplace is fully vented with a sealed glass front, then you can operate it continuously. If however your furnace is ventless and has doors which can easily open, we recommend that you don’t leave it on while out or going to sleep. Modern gas fireplaces, however, have an oxygen depletion sensor which shut off the unit when oxygen levels get low, this feature can allow you to leave your gas fireplace on for long periods.
  7. Do gas fireplaces use a lot of gas?

    No. The best gas fireplaces do not use a lot of gas. We can calculate the amount of gas spent per hour by dividing the number of BTUs by 1,000 to get the number of cubic feet burned per hour. Then we multiply that answer by the current price of gas, and we get the hourly operation cost. For example; if your gas uses 40,000 BTUs per hour, divided by 1,000, we get 40 cubic feet per hour. Assuming gas costs $0.0042 per cubic foot, then 40 multiplied by $0.0042 will equal $0.17 per hour. This means your gas fireplace uses 17 cents of gas an hour.
  8. Do gas fireplaces need to be vented?

    Not all of them. Some gas fireplaces have been designed to function without a flue or chimney fully. The use of gas brings about carbon monoxide, so we advise that you properly ventilate the room in which the fireplace is.
  9. How long do gas fireplace logs last?

    A well maintained vented ceramic log set can last up to 10 or more years. A well maintained ventless ceramic log can last up to 5years when heavily used.
  10. Is it safe to leave the pilot light on a gas fireplace?

    Leaving the pilot light on means there is still a continuous flow of gas, which may pose a safety hazard. Most gas fireplaces, however, come with oxygen depletion sensors which turn off the pilot light when the oxygen levels go below a given point.

Related: 10 Best Propane & Natural Gas Fireplace Inserts

Related: 12 Best Gas Log Fireplace Inserts and Reviews

Related: 18 Best Electric Fireplace Reviews & Guide

About the author

FireplaceLab

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment